The Two Great Factors That Hinder Us from Experiencing and Enjoying
Christ
—“Murmurings”
vs. “Reasonings”
According to the Bible and based on the information
provided, the burden of Philippians 2:14-16 is not merely that we should correct
two bad habits. Rather, we need to be saved from the realm of reason, right and wrong, doubt, and dissatisfaction,
and be brought into the realm of life, light, and Christ as the Head, so
that we may become luminaries, shining forth Christ.
Philippians 2:14-15: “Do all things without murmurings and reasonings, that you may be blameless and
guileless, children of God without blemish in the midst of a crooked and perverted generation, among whom you shine as luminaries in
the world.”
An
Integrated Table
|
Spiritual Item |
Murmurings |
Reasonings |
Their Common Spiritual
Essence |
|
Basic Meaning |
To be dissatisfied and complain secretly or openly; including faultfinding,
grumbling, inward disputing, displeasure, and complaining |
Disputing and questioning with a tone of unbelief
or doubt; including debating, doubting, reasoning, making judgments, and drawing conclusions |
The reaction of the
natural man toward God, others, or circumstances,
leaving life and falling into the realm of
reason |
|
Outward Expression |
“Why is it like this?” “Why do I have to suffer
this?” “Why can others do this but not me?” |
“Is this really right?” “I think it should be...”
“We must first make this clear.” |
Negative words,
thoughts, theories, and conclusions issue from within |
|
Inward Source |
Dissatisfaction, unhappiness, and unwillingness to accept the Lord's arrangement |
Unbelief, doubt, self-confidence, and natural
reasoning |
The self, the natural life, the natural mind, and the strongholds of thought formed by Satan
within man |
|
Primary Realm |
Feelings, emotions, the will, and speech |
The mind, thoughts, concepts, theories, and speech |
The soul-life has not been brought under
Christ's headship |
|
Spiritual Direction |
From enjoying Christ to focusing on circumstances |
From contacting Christ to analyzing matters |
Turning from Christ to oneself, circumstances, right
and wrong, and reasons |
|
The Problem of “Reasons” |
Because the circumstances do not satisfy the self,
murmuring arises |
Because something does not agree with one's
understanding, reasoning begins |
Man thinks that he needs a reason, but “I
am Jehovah” is itself the highest reason |
|
Biblical Example |
The children of Israel murmured in the wilderness and suffered God's judgment |
Man questions God's way through his own thoughts, reasonings, and doubts |
Israel's
history became a warning and example to us—1 Cor. 10:10-11 |
|
The Warning in 1 Corinthians 10:10 |
“Neither murmur, even as some of them murmured and perished by the
destroyer.” |
Although reasonings are not mentioned directly in
this verse, they are likewise forbidden in Phil. 2:14 |
Both murmurings and
reasonings can damage God's people's enjoyment of
Christ |
|
Relationship to Life |
Murmuring causes us to lose our enjoyment
of the Lord |
Reasoning causes us to lose our trust in
the Lord |
Both cause us to leave the realm of life |
|
Relationship to Light |
Murmuring causes us to lose inward joy and light |
Reasoning brings the mind into darkness, confusion,
and
doubt |
We lose Christ's shining
and are unable to function as luminaries |
|
Relationship to Christ |
We no longer take Christ as our satisfaction but take favorable circumstances as our
satisfaction |
We no longer take Christ as the answer but make our own reasoning the answer |
The inward operation of Christ in us is hindered |
|
Relationship to Enjoying Christ |
“I am dissatisfied; therefore, I cannot enjoy.” |
“I do not understand; therefore, I cannot enjoy.” |
Christ as our satisfaction replaces satisfaction with
circumstances; trusting Christ replaces
natural understanding |
|
Relationship to Prayer |
Murmuring can cause prayer to become complaining |
Reasoning can cause prayer to become arguing with God and demanding explanations |
Genuine prayer
brings us back to the spirit and into fellowship with the Lord |
|
Relationship to Thanksgiving |
Murmuring is the opposite of giving thanks |
Reasoning is the opposite of trusting |
Joy, prayer, and thanksgiving are life practices that counteract murmurings and reasonings |
|
Relationship to Praise |
Murmuring causes us to look at circumstances rather
than the Lord |
Reasoning causes us to look at problems rather than
the Lord |
Praise turns us
from circumstances and problems to the Lord Himself |
|
Relationship to Living Christ |
We live ourselves and therefore have opinions about our circumstances |
We live ourselves and therefore insist on our own conclusions |
To live Christ is to allow Christ to be our life,
content, inward operating power, and answer |
|
Relationship to Philippians 2:13 |
We ignore that “it is God who operates in you for His good
pleasure” |
We do not trust God's inward operating but try to deal with matters by our own thoughts |
Phil. 2:13 → Phil. 2:14: Because God is
operating within us, we do not need to murmur or reason |
|
Relationship to Philippians 2:15 |
We lose the purity and simplicity of our expression |
We lose our shining testimony |
Being delivered from both enables us to be children of God
and luminaries |
|
Relationship to Satan |
Satan uses circumstances to stir up dissatisfaction |
Satan uses thoughts, theories, and reasoning to build up
strongholds |
Murmuring is more related to emotion and the will; reasoning is more related to the mind and theories,
but both can be utilized by Satan |
|
Spiritual Warfare |
We need to deal with negative feelings, words, and reactions |
We need to deal with thoughts, theories,
reasonings, and self-made conclusions |
“Taking captive
every thought unto the obedience of Christ”—2 Cor. 10:5 |
|
Expression of Rebellion |
Murmuring in speech |
Reasoning in thoughts and theories |
Rebellion against God may be expressed in our words,
thoughts, and theories |
|
What We Need to Be Saved From |
Dissatisfaction, faultfinding, grumbling, and complaining |
Doubt, natural reasoning, debating, and drawing conclusions |
Being saved out of the realm of “reasons” |
|
“A Blessed Blindness” |
Not murmuring because of what we see in our
circumstances |
Not judging the Lord's ways according to natural analysis |
Under the authority of the Lord's light, we do not replace Christ with our own judgment
but simply live under His headship |
|
The Realm of Life vs. the Realm of Right and Wrong |
“Do I like this?” |
“Is this right?” |
Turning from the realm of right and wrong to the realm
of life |
|
Under the Authority of Darkness vs. Under the Authority
of Light |
Murmuring brings us into negativity and darkness |
Reasoning causes us to fall into the darkness of
the mind |
Col. 1:12-13: We are transferred out of
the authority of darkness into the kingdom of the
Son of God's love |
|
Christ as the Head |
Not accepting the Lord's arrangement |
Not accepting the Lord's sovereignty |
When we live under Christ's headship, we do not need to manufacture reasons for His
arrangements |
|
Practical Way of Dealing with It |
Bring dissatisfaction to the Lord and turn to Him in the spirit |
Give doubts and reasonings to the Lord and stop the
self in the spirit |
“Stop the self → Return to the spirit →
Contact the Lord → Receive the Lord” |
|
Positive Replacement |
Replace murmuring with joy, thanksgiving, and praise |
Replace reasoning with trust, prayer, and submission |
Not suppressing ourselves, but allowing Christ as life
to replace our natural reactions |
|
The Way to Enjoy Christ |
Accept the
circumstances measured out by the Lord |
Accept the Lord
Himself as the
answer |
Enjoy Christ as life, the word of life, and the inward operating power |
|
Ultimate Result |
We no longer lose Christ because of circumstances |
We no longer lose Christ because of problems |
Christ can shine within us and through us |
|
The Result in Philippians 2:15 |
“Shine as luminaries in the world” |
||
|
Ultimate Goal |
That Christ may be expressed, that God may be glorified, and that the Body of Christ may become a shining testimony |
||
An
Important Spiritual Line
These two matters are not merely two unrelated bad habits. They form a
complete spiritual sequence:
Circumstances do not satisfy us
↓
Murmurings
↓
Inward dissatisfaction
↓
Turning to ourselves and our circumstances
↓
The mind begins to analyze
↓
Reasonings
↓
Doubt → Natural reasoning → Theories → Conclusions
↓
Falling into the realm of “right and wrong /
reasons”
↓
Losing the enjoyment of Christ
↓
Christ cannot operate
freely within us
↓
Unable to
shine as luminaries
The opposite way, the way of life, is:
Circumstances /
Experiences
↓
Return to the spirit
↓
Contact Christ
↓
Believe that He is operating
within us (Phil. 2:13)
↓
Enjoy the word of life
↓
Remain in fellowship through
prayer
↓
Joy + Thanksgiving + Praise
↓
Accept Christ as life and accept His
headship
↓
Without murmurings and reasonings
↓
Live Christ
↓
Shine as luminaries
↓
Express Christ
↓
Glorify God
“Reasons”
Are the Deeper Common Problem
A particularly important point is found in
the information concerning Leviticus 18 through 22.
Whenever God commanded His people concerning
how they should live and act, He
repeatedly inserted the declaration:
“I am
Jehovah.”
He did not always give a long explanation or even use
the word because.
This reveals a very important spiritual principle: “I am Jehovah” is greater than “I need a reason.”
|
The Realm of the Natural Man |
The Realm of Life |
|
Why? |
Lord, I trust
You. |
|
I do not understand. |
Lord, You
Yourself are my answer. |
|
Is this reasonable? |
Is this from
You? |
|
I do not think it should be this way. |
I am willing to
accept Your sovereignty. |
|
I must first understand everything. |
I must first
contact You. |
|
I need to judge right and wrong. |
I need to live
in life. |
|
I need to find a reason. |
“I am Jehovah.” |
|
My thoughts are the head. |
Christ is the Head. |
|
The realm of right and wrong |
The realm of life |
|
The authority of darkness |
The kingdom of the Son of God's love |
|
Natural reaction |
The operation of Christ |
Therefore, “a blessed blindness” does not mean being foolish or
abandoning proper discernment. Rather, it means
that we do not allow natural reasons, natural analysis, and self-made
judgments to replace Christ. Instead, under the authority of light and in the realm of life, we
simply submit to Christ as the Head.
The
Inward Contrast Between the Two Great Hindrances
These two matters may be summarized in a simple contrast:
|
Murmurings |
Reasonings |
|
Rebellion in
emotion |
Rebellion in
the mind |
|
I do not like it. |
I do not agree with it. |
|
I am dissatisfied. |
I do not understand. |
|
Complaining |
Debating |
|
Grumbling |
Developing theories |
|
Faultfinding |
Drawing conclusions |
|
Displeasure |
Doubting |
|
Having opinions about circumstances |
Having opinions about God's way |
|
“Why is it
like this?” |
“On what
basis should it be like this?” |
|
Losing joy |
Losing trust |
|
Leaving enjoyment |
Leaving fellowship |
|
Turning to
circumstances |
Turning to
the mind |
|
We need to return to the spirit |
We need to return to the spirit |
|
Replace it with thanksgiving |
Replace it with trust |
|
Replace it with praise |
Replace it with prayer |
|
Enjoy Christ |
Contact Christ |
|
Live Christ |
Let Christ be the Head |
Four
Crucial Turns for Our Deliverance
1. From Circumstances to Christ
The circumstances may not change, but we
first change the object of our attention.
Instead of asking: “Why are my circumstances like this?”
we may ask:
“Lord, how much of Yourself do
You desire to dispense into me through these circumstances?”
2. From Reasons to Life
We do not first seek explanations; we first contact life.
The natural sequence is: Reasons → Right and Wrong → Reasonings
But the way of life is:
Christ →
Life → Fellowship → Enjoyment
3. From the Self as the Head to
Christ as the Head
The real question is not merely: “Who is right and who is
wrong?”
The deeper question is: “Who
is the head?”
If the self is the head, there will inevitably be
reasons, analyses, judgments, and reasonings.
If Christ is the Head, there will be
submission, life, light, and rest.
4. From Murmurings and Reasonings to Joy, Thanksgiving, and Praise
Philippians 4 gives us a very practical way:
Rejoice always → Pray → In everything bring
your requests to God with thanksgiving → The
peace of God guards our hearts and thoughts (Phil. 4:4-7).
Therefore, overcoming murmurings and reasonings is not
merely a matter of saying:
“I should not complain.”
Rather, it is a matter of:
Replacing dissatisfaction with the joy of Christ, reasonings with prayer, complaining with
thanksgiving, and natural reactions with praise.
Practical
Exercise: A Simple Spiritual Formula
Whenever dissatisfaction begins to rise within us or we
feel inclined to argue and reason, we can immediately practice:
Stop → Return to
the spirit → Call on the Lord → Contact Christ → Enjoy the Lord's word → Pray →
Give thanks → Praise → Accept the Lord's sovereignty → Live Christ
In other words:
Murmurings / Reasonings
→ Return to the spirit
→ Contact Christ
→ Enjoy
the word of life
→ Remain in fellowship
→ Joy,
Thanksgiving, and Praise
→ Christ
operates within us
→ Live Christ
→ Shine as luminaries
A
Survey of the Related Scriptures
|
Scripture |
Spiritual Emphasis |
|
Philippians 2:13 |
God is
operating in us for His good pleasure |
|
Philippians 2:14 |
Do all things
without murmurings and reasonings |
|
Philippians 2:15 |
Be children of
God without blemish and shine as luminaries |
|
Philippians 2:16 |
Holding forth
the word of life |
|
1 Corinthians 10:10-11 |
Israel's
murmuring is a warning and example to us |
|
1 Timothy 1:3-6 |
Do not fall
into vain talking and disputing but remain in God's economy |
|
1 Timothy 6:3-4 |
Do not fall
into disputes and wranglings about words |
|
2 Corinthians 10:3-5 |
Cast down
reasonings
and every high thing, taking every thought captive
unto the obedience of Christ |
|
Colossians 1:12-13 |
We have been delivered from the
authority of darkness and transferred into the
kingdom of the Son of God's love |
|
Romans 9:20-21 |
The thing
formed should not argue with the One who formed it |
|
Romans 11:33-34 |
God's judgments
are unsearchable and His ways are untraceable |
|
Acts 22:10 |
“What shall I
do, Lord?”—turning to the Lord for His leading |
|
Acts 16:25 |
Paul and Silas
prayed and sang hymns of praise to God in prison |
|
Philippians 3:10 |
Knowing Christ and experiencing Christ |
|
Philippians 4:4 |
Rejoice in the
Lord always |
|
Philippians 4:6-7 |
By prayer,
petition, and thanksgiving, bring everything to God |
|
1 Thessalonians 5:16-20 |
Rejoice always,
pray unceasingly, give thanks in everything, and do not quench the Spirit |
An
Integrated Ministry Burden
According to the emphasis of the ministry of
concerning the experience of life, the
Christian problem is not merely that we speak too negatively
or have too many negative thoughts. The deeper
problem is this:
When
we live in the natural
life, we easily murmur;
when we live in the natural mind, we easily reason.
Therefore, the genuine
deliverance is not the improvement of the natural man but the replacement of the natural man by Christ:
Natural life → Christ as life
Natural mind → The
mind of Christ
Natural reasons → God's will
The realm of right and wrong → The realm of life
The self as the head → Christ as the Head
The authority of darkness → The kingdom of the Son of God's love
Murmurings and reasonings → Joy, prayer, thanksgiving, and praise
Unable to enjoy Christ → Living Christ and expressing
Christ
Ultimately, the goal of
Philippians 2 is not merely to make us people
who do not complain. The goal is:
“That you may become blameless and guileless, children of God
without blemish... among whom you shine as luminaries in the world.”
Therefore:
Not murmuring
and not reasoning are the negative side; living Christ
and shining as luminaries are the positive
side.
The crucial link between these two sides is Philippians 2:13—allowing
God to operate within us.
One-Sentence
Prophesying Summary
Murmuring is the heart's
dissatisfaction with circumstances, and reasoning is the mind's demand for
explanations from God and others; both cause us
to leave the realm of life and fall into the
realm of right and wrong. The way of deliverance is to
return to our spirit, remain in contact and
fellowship with Christ, enjoy Him as the word
of life, and live a life of joy, prayer,
thanksgiving, and praise by the wonderful
Spirit of the Triune God, so that we may live
Christ, shine as luminaries, and give Christ a
glorified expression.
*Please refer to the April
2026 Summer Training General Topic: Believers, Chapter Nine: Pillars and the
Glowing Body.